Our orders were very clear. Go to Dolores Park between the bell and the playground, holds hands and form circle(s), sit down, wait for something to happen and (according to the instructions): “You will instantly know how to play along.”
My friend Kirk and I join a circle, sit down, then a person three people down from me, gets up, and starts tapping people on the shoulders.
He taps some stranger. “Duck!”
Kirk. “Duck!”
And then me. “Goose!”
The sad, tragic moment where I realize that I have no clue how one plays “Duck! Duck! Goose!”
People all look to me, most saying the same thing. “Run!”
But run where?
Kirk says, “Run.”
The guy who started the game, looks at me, doubles back, tags me again and says “Goose?!” He wears a pleading look, desperately wanting me to say, “Oh! Duck, duck, goose!” and proceed to chase him.
I get up, chase after him, tag him, and somehow things proceed. Around me, I hear other people whispering the rules to other people. “When you are tagged, you chase the person that tagged you, they get to sit down, and then you have to pick the next goose.”
Our group is a rather large circle, 40 people maybe?, but we rarely have more than one or two people running around at any given time. A lot of people seem relieved when the person walking by them says “Duck” and keeps going.
After ten minutes, the crowd disperses as instructed to “run away!” War whoops and running and the square of land that was previously our playing field is now empty.
I’m not saying it wasn’t fun, but we seem to be missing the point of the flash mob here.
First of all, the location. While only 5 blocks from my apartment, I can’t really complain from a convenience standpoint, but Dolores Park was mainly filled with dogwalkers and sunbathers. Unlike the first flashmob, which was in a very tourist-centric location, this one was mainly targetting San Franciscans as our “audience.”
But, I just don’t think we were doing anything that would bring out that “What the hell is going on over there?” vibe. At Flash Mob #1, passerbys actually had no idea what was happening, but they joined in, which was less likely to happen here as well. Ultimately people watched, shrugged, and continued sunbathing as near as I could tell.
Also, it seems the tenets of the flash mob didn’t pan out this time. The park was mainly dog walkers and sun bathers, and our group appeared dog-less and a little too jeans-and-a-T-shirt to be sunbathers. So, we lose the notion that this was just some moment of communal insanity that just overtook people. We looked like people who arrived in the park if not together than with a common purpose. And the exit, with everyone running and hollaring and leaving the park, solidified the group notion.
On Flash Mob #1, there didn’t seem to be the same “gathering” and “dispersing” issues, and the mob gently disappearing back into society worked. If you compare our flashmobs to others, it seems that most of them stay more in the realm of propless performance art. It may just happen, but the guise of it being a random spontaneous act disappears quickly.
I think the mobs I’ve been most interested in are the most subtle. the New Yorkers on the hotel mazzanine enamored with something in the downstairs lobby that doesn’t exist and making everyone else wonder what they aren’t seeing. The spinning San Franciscans. I like it when people aren’t sure what is happening, but most mobs seem to scream that something is happening.
I think in the larger cities, the risk is the mob becoming the event, rather than the chaos surrounding the mob being the event. With a group of 100+ people, anything done in tandem will seem like an organized group as soon as it occurs. Of course, with the groups split up into at least four units beforehand, there is no actual need for everyone’s piece of paper to say the same thing, but that might be even harder to plan.
The ones whereby a lot of people enter a place of business seem to invite danger, which I saw firsthand as a drunken Santa last year. But, if any large group of people enter a place of business, dressed as Santa or not, they will freak out.
So, I guess what I look for in a flash mob are:
- location, location, location (areas targetting tourists, shoppers, and rush hour commuters are best)
- graceful entrance
- seemingly random event
- subtle, seemingly natural exit
Rather than just criticize (although I do appreciate the efforts of the people who do organize these things, I just want to make them better), I offer the following as examples of what I think would work:
– The most spastic group tai chi ever in Yerba Buena Gardens, and rather than everyone starting at once, let a few people start, then others join in, let it build. Keep it seeming organic.
– A group of people go to Pier 39 to see the sea lions, until some people learn that the animal’s squawking gives them sexual pleasure. And as some people start moaning in ecstasy to echo the sea lions groans, more people get pulled into the mix. This will be worth the video alone of tourists with kids quickly running away.
– Pick a block with a lot of bars and restaurants with bars, and have people start at different locations within the set-up and at the proper time, they all exit their location, go to their right, enter the next place of business and ask something (which will result in every place saying no, at least when they initially bother to reply), and this also helps disperse the large crowd by having people enter businesses in smaller groups.
– You can also do the above, and instead of going into any businesses, everyone walks out to the street, finds a parking meter, and starts rubbing it. Ecstatically.
Of course, if we play Duck, Duck, Goose! again, I’m ready this time!